Can government keep up with AI? The fate of a broadband grant program might tell us.

fotograzia via Getty Images
COMMENTARY | It’s been five years since Congress approved BEAD. Now, states and the federal government should ensure projects are viable and get grant money flowing.
Lost amid the uproar over artificial intelligence is an unfortunate irony: at a time when many are grappling with the myriad uncertainties created by this rapidly evolving technology, about 5 million households across the U.S. still lack high-speed internet access.
How can this be? After all, five years ago Congress allocated $42.45 billion to close the digital divide once and for all via a grant program known as the Broadband Equity, Accessibility and Deployment program. Unfortunately, BEAD sputtered for years during the Biden administration and only recently has gotten on track. However, after years of delay, the contours of the problem that BEAD was created to solve have changed markedly.
There are now far fewer people in the U.S. without a broadband connection than there were when BEAD was created. This is due primarily to continued investment by private internet service providers.
Indeed, according to research conducted by New York Law School's Advanced Communications Law and Policy Institute, where I serve as director, the digital divide has closed by 79% since Dec. 2022. Over that period, more than 7 million locations got broadband for the first time; of those, about 63% were built by broadband providers without any federal subsidy. So, rather than wait for BEAD funds to flow, ISPs kept building.
Though great news for many in rural America, where broadband has long lagged, this continued expansion has scrambled the BEAD map, so much so that many of the grant projects approved by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, the federal agency administering BEAD, no longer target mostly unserved communities.
In BEAD’s first round, ISPs won more than $19 billion to serve 3.8 million locations, which were bundled together into project areas. Federal law requires these areas to include at least 80% of locations without access to a broadband connection. At one point in time, each of BEAD’s round one awards passed this test; now, we estimate less than one-third do. Unless these awards are altered to reflect newly served locations, NTIA risks subsidizing massive overbuilding of existing network infrastructure.
NTIA and its counterparts in the states also face the challenge of ensuring that as many locations as possible are served with available funding, the core mission of the law that created BEAD.
After BEAD’s first round, we found that, for a variety of reasons, 1.1 million locations were at risk of being omitted from BEAD and recommended that some of the $21 billion in unspent grant funds be used to connect them. In response, NTIA announced a second round of BEAD for these overlooked locations. The task now is to make sure this round reaches all those places.
This might sound like small-stakes insider baseball, but if we want to finally close the digital divide and win the AI race, we need government to move quicker when addressing core technology issues. That’s why the fate of BEAD matters.
NTIA has shown it can adjust on the fly in the face of new facts on the ground, as evidenced by its launch of a second round of BEAD. While a welcome first step, NTIA must also make sure grants made to date accurately reflect the changing BEAD map.
To do that, NTIA should direct states to confirm with ISPs, within a limited window of, say, 30 days, which grant projects are still viable. If projects are still viable, funds should flow quickly.
If projects are no longer viable, NTIA should let states quickly rescope BEAD projects by stripping out locations that are already served to create more workable project areas. Communities and families without a connection should not have to wait any longer to be served.
Finally, NTIA must address documented cost increases and plan for inevitable replacement projects after withdrawals or defaults. During the pendency of BEAD, material and labor costs have shot up. Similarly, as projects move to the build stage, stakeholders are encountering profoundly inefficient administrative processes when negotiating space on utility poles to place equipment and securing the permits needed to build.
We estimate that BEAD projects will touch about 4 million utility poles and require at least 11 permits from eight different permitting authorities. Left unaddressed, these chokepoints will delay construction and put enormous pressure on project budgets. NTIA should earmark some of the billions in unspent BEAD funds to offset verifiable cost increases and ensure that there are resources on hand for likely defaults.
Connecting all Americans to broadband has become a real-world test of a question that AI will force us to answer again and again: Can government consistently hit a moving target?
The answer should be yes. But to get there, Washington must recognize changing circumstances, adjust policy quickly, and focus relentlessly on results. Getting BEAD right will not just connect the last Americans waiting for broadband — it will show that policymakers can keep pace with the technologies reshaping the country.
Michael Santorelli is Director of the Advanced Communications Law & Policy Institute (ACLP) at New York Law School.




