Report: Four ways agencies can enhance their public benefit infrastructure

jetcityimage via Getty Images
Public benefit systems are under-delivering, but states can take steps to improve how they ensure eligible residents are getting the assistance they need, including through better use of data.
As states navigate new and complex rules for public benefit programs, a new report offers insights on how agencies can make those programs more efficient and effective.
More than $227 billion in authorized funds go unused for public assistance programs, which means millions of Americans are without the support for food assistance, health care and tax credits they could be entitled to, according to a report released last week by the Roosevelt Institute.
The report offers four strategies to reform benefits administration, which it estimates could unlock an additional $49 billion in annual financial assistance to around 18 million people across the U.S.
While the report highlights how a future federal administration could reform benefits delivery, “a lot of takeaways are directly applicable for state and local officials” as “many programs in the social safety net are administered at the state level,” Ivana Ng, a product strategist at the Roosevelt Institute and the report’s author, told Route Fifty.
One priority area the report identified for states to consider is leveraging existing legal pathways to optimize program eligibility and enrollment processes.
“Oftentimes, government agencies make people fill out applications and provide documentation that are not actually required by federal law. This paperwork is an affirmative choice agencies make in the face of complex requirements and limited implementation support,” the report says.
As an example, Ng pointed to the broad-based categorical eligibility mechanism under the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, which allows states to raise the income limit for people to qualify for SNAP if they also receive noncash assistance from the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program. The process also lets states increase the threshold for or forgo the program’s asset test, which is conducted to determine if a beneficiary’s property or savings disqualify them for receiving assistance.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture proposed a rule to end the broad-based categorical eligibility process last week, a move that could cut off SNAP benefits for an estimated 6.3 million people once it is in effect.
If approved, the rule change would significantly disrupt states’ efforts to enhance the accuracy and efficiency of a social safety net program like SNAP, Ng said.
The broad-based categorical eligibility option can help states tap into benefit funds that would go unspent otherwise, while also offering agencies a way to reduce SNAP payment error rates, she explained. Beginning Oct. 1, 2027, states with a SNAP payment error rate above 6% will have to pay a larger portion under the program’s cost-share model with the federal government.
Eliminating the asset test or making it less stringent can help reduce the introduction of errors in beneficiary documentation and staff calculations of people’s property, which research shows can “add a full percentage point to the state’s overall error rate,” according to the report.
More efficient use of data is another way states can enhance safety net service delivery and hold themselves accountable when serving their residents, Ng said, who added that it is “what keeps people from getting the help they need,” not just complicated policies and programming snags.
“[M]ost wage verification for benefits programs relies on one of two things: quarterly wage reports pulled from state databases, or the applicant manually submitting recent pay stubs. Neither gets benefits into someone’s hands faster, and neither is paperwork-free,” the report says.
States could establish more frequent data reporting requirements, such as collecting wage data every pay period, Ng said.
The Department of Labor sent a letter to state unemployment insurance directors in July urging them to “seriously consider enhancing their wage records” to stamp out fraudulent and improper unemployment insurance payments, the report says. Increasing the frequency of employer wage reporting is one way to do that, according to the letter.
Indeed, “states are independently considering legislation that would require pay-period wage reporting for unemployment insurance, and some have the authority to make this change via executive action. There is both federal and state-level appetite for this, and the federal government has an opportunity to facilitate and fund a more streamlined, governed implementation,” the report says.
The report also points to the importance of building public digital infrastructure to enable better benefit service delivery. Relying heavily on external products can lead to implementation delays, program errors and excessive spending for agencies.
“It’s really important to not outsource the technology and know-how to commercial vendors,” Ng said, adding that states should not “let vendors own your policy and program rules.”
For instance, “at least 25 states have hired Deloitte to build their Medicaid eligibility systems, in contracts worth at least $5 billion combined. Each of these states is paying hundreds of millions of dollars at a time to essentially ‘build’ the same commodity 25 times over,” the report says.
Public platforms must include basic functions like identity verification, wage verification, benefit disbursement and notification services, but agencies should consider several design principles that mitigate the risk of a government-owned system encroaching on or risking their residents’ privacy, according to the report.
For instance, state agencies could design a benefit system to be decentralized “so that there is no single point of failure and no single point of abuse,” the report says.
A zero-trust design should also be a standard for states to consider when building their own public benefit systems, according to the report.
“No system should trust another by default. Every request between agencies should be authenticated and verified at the moment, and every actor’s access should be scoped to exactly the subset of data or function needed for the action at hand,” it says.
Ultimately, “digital infrastructure must be shared, open and reusable” to “deliver economic relief faster and more automatically,” the report says.
Lastly, states should increasingly lean on community-based organizations as they look to strengthen safety net programs, particularly as agencies grapple with shrinking staff and budget resources, Ng said.
“The front door to government doesn't have to be a government building or website,” she said. Local libraries, food banks and other community-based organizations are a resource for governments to help link residents with assistive programs and services, Ng added.
As an example, she pointed to the Texas Health and Human Services Commission, which launched a program in 2012 through which local partners and networks can help residents apply for and enroll in assistance programs. Today, more than 500 community partners across 252 counties participate in the program.
“These community-based organizations can also be advocates for the people who are applying and almost serve as a check on the government services,” Ng said, explaining that community partners can communicate application or enrollment challenges to government agencies to inform future improvements to benefit systems.
Such efforts are crucial because “safety nets are not delivering today … and when the government can’t keep its work, people stop believing it can work for them,” Ng said, adding the way to improve safety net delivery “is to take the guesswork out.”




